03/24/2026
A Tale of Two Headlines
(Involving vehicles and assault)
Out of Lexington Kentucky we have the story of 20-year-old Kaydence Carpenter.
Last Sunday morning (Saturday night after the bars closed, really) young Ms. Carpenter found herself with a considerable number of people milling about in the parking lot, apparently exchanged some words, got into her Tesla and after some preliminaries, drove through the crowd, striking multiples persons with her car.
In other news, celebrity star of “Reacher” and other TV and movies, Alan Ritchson was involved in an altercation with a neighbor while Mr. Ritchson was on his motorcycle. Mr. Ritchson was with his two sons on their own motorcycles during daylight when confronted by the neighbor, and subsequently a fistfight broke out between the two men.
So let’s discuss road rage for a moment. Links to articles will be in comments on the original post- click through to this page).
I have said before on numerous occasions that being trapped in your vehicle in an aggressive crowd of pedestrians is a dangerous situation that can, in some circumstances justify using your vehicle as a weapon to force your way free of danger. It’s not a light decision and we certainly want to avoid it if at all possible.
Witness testimony and video from Ms. Carpenter’s incident is pretty clear. There was a crowd of unruly people. Very likely most of them had been drinking. There may have been a racial and or sexual component to comments tossed about towards Ms. Carpenter. What we don’t see on the video is any attempt to physically accost her or damage her car. There is some disrespectful and unjustified contact with her vehicle. A guy plops his rear on her hood and slides down it. Not particularly showing intent to damage it; just disrespect and disdain- ‘coup-counting’.
Carpenter backs her car up into the ‘lane’ of the parking lot. She then moves her car back into the parking stall. One might opine it is abruptly, in a threatening manner. She backs up again. She does not turn her wheels during these maneuvers as if she will exit the parking lot via the designated exit. After backing up the second time, she guns the vehicle forward into the parking stall, over the concrete curb stop, over the sidewalk, and over the curb into the street.
She strikes several people and risks striking several more. A narrator of cell phone video captured makes it clear her intentions were obvious; the narrator warns people repeatedly that Carpenter is about to ram them.
Police pull Carpenter over soon after, not far away, going the wrong direction down the street. Officers assessed her as impaired due to drinking (refused breath test, smelled of alcohol, slurred speech, eyes showed signs of intoxication, failed field sobriety test at the station.) She was also in possession of a fake ID. They charged her with multiple assaults and DUII.
Some people are holding this girl up like a poster child… I can only because she is white and most of the crowd were black. They cite a “rowdy mob”. This young lady is no hero, and she is not a victim. Yes, there was a rowdy crowd of drunk people there. She was part of it. No matter what anybody said, there is no visible justification for a claim of self defense or need to escape. She made multiple threatening gestures with her car, but never tried to simply drive it to the exit and leave before ramming pedestrians. She used her car to punish people for disrespect (to stretch the point in her favor) not to defend herself or even avoid damage to property. In fact, driving over the curb stop almost certainly caused more damage to her car than anything else.
On to Mr. Ritchson.
The neighbor involved claims Ritchson has made a habit of riding his motorcycle at high speed through the neighborhood, revving loudly, and making a nuisance/danger of himself. The altercation was first published as a view from inside a house with no audio, showing Ritchson off his motorcycle bike laid down) and punching Mr. Taylor. Subsequent video posted by Mr. Taylor himself admits to pushing Ritchson while the latter was on his bike, and attempts to justify it. A body or helmet cam from Mr. Ritchson shows a more complete view from the beginning and includes some audio.
Mr. Taylor steps into the street to confront Mr. Ritchson. Whatever may have happened earlier, Mr. Ritchson’s video shows his speed as under 25 MPH which is consistent with neighborhood streets. Mr. Ritchson’s sons are on minibikes behind him and do not take part in the confrontation, but it is significant to note that a parent with their children in tow are more likely to feed a reasonable need to respond defensively.
Mr. Taylor physically blocks the road with his body while haranguing Ritchson. Video is less than perfectly clear, but witness statements, video, and Mr. Taylor’s statements all seem to agree Taylor pushed or struck Ritchson hard enough to knock him over and drop his bike at least twice. The video shows Mr. Taylor being pretty aggressive from the beginning, no attempt to wave down for a civil discussion, not preliminary conversation, just yelling and pushing. Ritchson gets off the bike (apparently still idling while laid down). At this point the men struggle and Ritchson punches Taylor several times. At least some of the punching is while Taylor is standing fully upright, and perhaps even while he is on the ground. Ritchson gives multiple directions to “stay down”. This may give a shallow impression being a dominance move, but remember that “violence often comes with instructions on how to avoid it.”
Taylor started the physical aggression and participated in it with more shoving and possibly punching while being punched by Ritchson, despite the fight seeming to go mostly one way (Ritchson is a very large, physically fit man, and Taylor appears to be older, smaller, and less fit- the whole incident is pretty questionable wisdom on his part) Ritchson doesn’t kick Taylor or hit him more than seems necessary to make him stop returning to engagement. Once Taylor stays put for a few seconds, Ritchson retreats to his bike and puts his helmet back on to leave. Taylor then approaches once again, but wisely stays just out of punching range. Reasonable interpretation: Ritchson uses enough force to gain compliance and stop the threat, and retreats when it is safe and feasible. The interaction counts as road rage because Taylor initiated an interaction with a driver based on his perception of the driver’s behavior, blocking traffic and battering the driver (assault and battery- the assault is the threat or risk of physical damage, the laying on of hands is the battery part. Specifics of how this plays out vary slightly in legal language from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.) Mr. Taylor has a British accent, perhaps he hasn’t fully grasped American jurisprudence on assault and self-defense.
I would not be surprised to see charges filed on Mr. Taylor. Potentially a civil suit as well. Pushing a person over on a motorcycle could quite easily result in a serious bodily injury such as a broken leg. That bike weighs several hundred pounds. It undoubtedly resulted in damages to the bike itself.