11/02/2023
Conflicting Data and Inflation Decreasing! - "In some places" (11th February 2023)
-Investors digest a substantial amount of economic news
-U.S Corporate results: a mixed bag
-FTSE 100 reaches new highs
-E.U and U.S green subsidies – more than just about the environment.
Market sentiment: Risk appetite remains strong. Recessions in the Eurozone and the U.S may well be avoided, as inflation falls over the coming months and central banks end their interest rate hikes. Labour markets are robust, supporting demand. This suggests that corporate profits, and dividends will not be hit as much as had been feared just six weeks ago, when the macro-economic outlook appeared worse.
But central banks remain wary of core inflation (headline CPI inflation excluding energy and food), which is proving stubborn. The war on inflation is not over yet, as Jerome Powell of the Fed, and Christine Lagarde of the ECB, said last week, using almost identical wording to warn investors they may have to price in higher terminal interest rates than they are currently expecting.
Reassuringly, the riskiest assets have held onto their January gains despite the warnings on rates from the central banks. The tech-heavy NASDAQ is up 15% since the start of the year), while Bitcoin is up 37% to $22,731. Investors seem prepared to look through any near-term squalls on inflation and interest rate news.
Investors digest a substantial amount of economic news. The Fed, ECB and Bank of England all raised interest rates last week by the expected amount (25bps for the Fed, 50bps for the ECB and BoE). Investors were reassured that, while warning that terminal rates may be higher than currently priced in, neither the Fed nor the ECB are interested in over-doing the rate hikes. To use an a popular analogy, neither want to risk tackling a high temperature by killing the patient, as happened in the late 1970s/ early 1980s in much of the industrialised world.
The Bank of England went further, suggesting that its rate hike, which raised its key rate to 4.0%, may be the last one in the current cycle. The outlook for the U.K this year is one of shrinking GDP and increasing taxes. The IMF’s latest economic outlook, released last week, sees the U.K being the only major economy to suffer recession this year, with GDP down 0.5% in 2023 (it had forecasted an expansion of +0.1% in October). World GDP is expected to grow by 3.2%, up from 1.9% in 2022 but still well below the average between 2000 and 2019 of 3.8%.
The U.S labour market remains tight, with a much higher-than-expected 517,000 new jobs created in January, and unemployment falling to a record low of 3.4%. There is anecdotal evidence of employers unwilling to fire staff, despite weaker demand for their products, for fear of being under-staffed when the economic cycle picks up. Sure, Big Tech has announced the firing of large numbers of staff in recent weeks, releasing skilled people. But these are being snapped up by all industries eager to expand/improve their I.T capabilities. The tight labour market is a headache for the Fed, as it contributes to strong wage growth. However, Fed Chair Powell made clear last week that embedded inflation (caused by wage growth) is not yet a problem.
U.S Corporate results: a mixed bag. With half the S&P500 companies having reported their results so far, the data services company Factset estimate that the average fall in Q4 profits, over the same period of 2021, will be around 5.3%. This is calculated using the actual numbers of the companies that have announced so far, and consensus estimates from analysts of those yet to report. This is a relatively modest fall in profits, given the rapid pace of interest rate hikes since late 2021. Industrials and energy have outperformed, while consumer discretionary, consumer services and tech are the worst performing.
Last week saw Apple, Amazon and Alphabet all release weak numbers, amid warnings of decelerating revenue growth and promises to reduce costs. Meta drew attention away from a 4% fall in profits, and 55% fall in profits, by announcing a cut in its R&D budget on ‘metaverse’ inventions and a $40bn share buy-back program. Its shares bounced.
Globally, banks are benefiting from increased net interest margins, as they pass higher interest rates onto lenders while only modestly offering depositors better rates. Energy companies are reaping a ‘Putin dividend’, which brings with it renewed demands from some voters, in some countries, for a windfall tax on the sector.
FTSE100 reaches new high. Helped by record profits from Shell and BP, and solid results from banks, insurers, and consumer staples, the FTSE100 sits at a record high (7,941 as I write). The Bank of England’s hints that its rate increases may have peaked have also helped lift the index, although more than two thirds of its companies’ revenues originate overseas. With an expected dividend yield of 4.1% this year, and dividend payments generally well covered by earnings, it appears cheap by comparison with, say, the S&P500, and it is attracting overseas buying.
E.U and U.S green subsidies – more than just about the environment. E.U leaders meet today and tomorrow for a two-day summit. A key topic will be how the bloc should respond to President Biden’s $370bn package of Federal subsidies, for clean energy projects, announced last August in the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). Of course, the name of the act is bizarre: increasing state spending, at a time of high inflation, will do nothing to bring prices down.
But the real problem with the program is that it distorts global investment in green energy. It is already sucking in projects from around the world, helped by a thicket of additional state and local tax breaks and subsidies. Europe and Asia risk losing their technology base in this sector, as their leading companies shirk Paris, France in favour of Paris, Texas. The result could be that the U.S and China dominate clean energy, able to charge monopoly prices in their spheres of influence.
Hope amongst European and Asian countries, that clean energy might help power their own technology renaissance, would be dashed. In response, last week the E.U announced that member states may offer a total of Euro 250bn tax credits and subsidies to their green sectors.
On the table at the Brussels summit are proposals to develop E.U ‘national champions’ (an idea France is particular keen on), and a relaxation of E.U state aid and competition (anti-trust) laws. Smaller E.U states fear E.U national champions will come from the larger countries, which will also offer outsized tax breaks that tempt away their own tech companies. They will have done to them by France, Germany etc, what the U.S is doing to Europe.
Many politicians in E.U member states have never felt easy with the free-market Anglo-Saxon culture that the U.K forced onto the European corporate landscape during its period of membership. They welcome the excuse to return to a more cosy (and opaque) relationship between big business and politics. The irony is that they can point to the U.S, as the example that they are following.
The U.K government is also placing a lot of hope in the green energy sector. But it has been muted in its criticism of the IRA, as it seeks Washington’s blessing on the revised Northern Ireland Protocol. Britain’s unilateral tearing-up of the original Protocol deal with the E.U angered Biden, and united Congress against proceeding with a U.K/U.S trade deal.
Investors should remain diversified. Investors should remain diversified in multi-asset portfolios, that offer exposure to equities, bonds and alternative asset classes. Holding cash is tempting, but it suggests an ability to ‘time the market’, to invest it at an optimum point in the cycle. Experience suggests this is very hard to achieve consistently.