09/03/2026
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1F8edyYGuW/
WHEN GOOD BREEDERS GATEKEEP, MEDIOCRE BREEDERS WIN
I had a conversation with a young woman today who wants to become a Labrador breeder.
She told me how incredibly difficult it has been to find established breeders who will even talk to her.
And that bothered me.
Anyone who knows me knows that I am NOT a phone person. If you call me, there is a very good chance I am staring at the phone waiting for it to stop ringing. đ But when a conversation needs to happenâespecially when someone genuinely wants to learnâI will pick up the damn phone.
Because here is what happened when good breeders wouldnât talk to this young woman:
She bought a puppy from a mediocre breeder who would.
The breeder health tests, and I absolutely give credit for that. Health testing is important. But health testing alone does not make a breeding program.
They donât title their dogs. They arenât proving them in conformation or performance. And when I looked at the pedigree of the puppy she purchased with hopes of eventually breeding, there was almost nothing there demonstrating generations of dogs being evaluated, proven and purposefully selected.
There was one title buried in the fourth generation on the damâs side and only a few that far back on the sireâs side.
That isnât a pedigree I would deliberately choose to carry forward into another generation.
And yet I donât blame this young woman nearly as much as some people probably would.
She tried to find better.
Better wouldnât answer the phone.
We need to have a serious conversation in the purebred dog world about gatekeeping.
We spend an enormous amount of time complaining about backyard breeders, mediocre breeding programs and people breeding dogs without understanding structure, temperament, working ability, pedigrees or breed type.
Then someone new comes along and says:
âI want to learn. I want to do this correctly. Will someone teach me?â
And too often the response is silence.
We wonât sell them a good prospect.
We wonât share our pedigrees.
We wonât explain why we made a breeding.
We wonât teach them how to evaluate a pedigree.
We wonât explain why CH, GCH, MH, SH, JH, obedience, rally and other titles matterâor what those titles actually tell us and, equally important, what they donât tell us.
We wonât teach them how to evaluate structure.
We wonât explain COI, linebreeding, outcrossing, phenotype versus genotype, longevity, temperament, health clearances or the strengths and weaknesses hiding behind the names on a pedigree.
Sometimes we wonât even have a conversation with them.
Then we act surprised when they buy from the breeder who will.
There is an important distinction here:
Mentorship does not mean handing your best puppy to everyone who says they want to breed.
We should absolutely screen people. We should protect our dogs. We should have standards. We should say no when necessary.
But protecting a bloodline and gatekeeping knowledge are two very different things.
And I think sometimes we have confused the two.
A pedigree shouldnât be treated like a treasure map weâre terrified someone might steal.
A great pedigree represents decades of decisions made by breeders before us. Studying those pedigreesâunderstanding what worked, what didnât, what certain dogs produced and why particular combinations were madeâis how the next generation learns.
None of us invented the Labrador Retriever.
None of us created these bloodlines from nothing.
We are temporary custodians of something generations of breeders built before us.
If we want this breed to be better 20 or 30 years from now, somebody has to teach the people who will still be breeding Labradors when many of us are gone.
That doesnât mean lowering our standards.
It means teaching other people how to raise theirs.
Imagine if instead of telling every aspiring breeder, âYou havenât earned access to these dogs,â we sometimes said:
âLet me show you what youâre looking at.â
âLet me explain why I wouldnât breed that dog.â
âLet me show you what I look for in a pedigree.â
âCome to a dog show with me.â
âCome watch a hunt test.â
âLetâs look at these dogs together.â
âIâll help you find the right foundation bitch.â
Will every person we mentor become a great breeder?
Of course not.
Some will quit.
Some will make mistakes.
Some will eventually make decisions we disagree with.
So did we.
Nobody entered this sport knowing everything.
Someone answered our questions.
Someone showed us a dog.
Someone explained a pedigree.
Someone trusted us with something worth building upon.
And somewhere along the way, somebody probably took a chance on us.
There is another side to this conversation too.
If you are a new breeder asking established breeders for access to their dogs, understand that mentorship isnât an entitlement. Be willing to listen. Be willing to show dogs. Work them. Health test them. Learn the standard. Accept criticism. Study pedigrees beyond the first generation. Ask why instead of simply asking what should I breed to?
Prove that you want to contribute something meaningful to the Labrador Retrieverânot simply produce puppies.
But those of us who have been here awhile have a responsibility too.
We can either help serious newcomers understand what responsible breeding looks likeâŚ
or mediocre breeders will happily teach them what mediocre breeding looks like.
Because mediocre breeders rarely gatekeep.
Theyâll sell the breeding prospect.
Theyâll answer the message.
Theyâll take the deposit.
And theyâll tell a newcomer everything is âbreeding quality.â
If the preservation-breeding community becomes so inaccessible that a sincere beginner cannot find a mentor, cannot purchase a genuinely promising foundation dog and cannot even get someone knowledgeable to answer their questions, we shouldnât be shocked when they end up somewhere else.
We should be asking ourselves how they got there.
Protect your dogs.
Protect your bloodlines.
Maintain high standards.
Choose carefully who you mentor.
But donât gatekeep the knowledge and pedigrees that could help someone become the kind of breeder we keep saying this breed desperately needs.
Because every time we slam the door on someone sincerely trying to learn, there is usually another breeder standing down the road with the door wide open.
And that breeder may be producing exactly what weâre trying to prevent.
We donât protect the Labrador Retriever by keeping good breeding in a closed circle.
We protect it by making sure the next generation knows how to do it better.
