06/19/2026
Are You Setting Your Supervisors Up for Success?
One of the most critical and challenging transitions, in my experience, occurs when a front-line staff member is first promoted into a supervisory position.
This becomes even more complicated when they are asked to supervise their “former” peers.
Without sufficient direction, support and training, this could fast become dysfunctional – for the supervisor, the team and the overall organization. This happens when:
1. The supervisor could blindly align with the team, refusing to address material operational, performance and behavioral concerns, and failing to report these issues to management in a timely manner, if at all;
2. The supervisor could favor certain team members over others (typically, coworkers with whom they have worked closely), resulting in conflict amongst the team and a loss of trust in the supervisor; or
3. The supervisor’s promotion could go to their head, resulting in a misuse or abuse of authority, and an overbearing “I know best” attitude over team members. Many team members share that their supervisor was amazing as a coworker but then changed into someone who didn’t seem to care about those who now reported to them.
Supervisors (and their staff) need to be educated on perceived and real conflicts of interest, the dangers of favoritism and the need for consistent and respectful team accountability. They can’t learn this through osmosis, mind-reading, or walking down the hall to find someone with the answers. Workplace supervision has grown too complicated for this laissez-faire approach. It is incumbent on more senior leaders and HR to set up first-time leaders for success. Otherwise, the failures are not theirs to own.