17/06/2026
A university has been ordered to pay more than £264,000 after an Employment Tribunal found a former employee had been unfairly dismissed and later victimised through a retaliatory reference.
The case centred around a long-running breakdown in the working relationship between an employee and her manager. Following mediation and disciplinary action, the employee was dismissed after being unable to secure another role internally.
The Tribunal found:
✔ The dismissal process was unfair
✔ Full details of allegations were not properly provided
✔ The employee’s appeal was not heard
✔ A later reference stating the university was “still in dispute” with the employee amounted to victimisation
The total award included future loss of earnings, pension loss and injury to feelings.
Patricia Colden commented:
“Many Tribunal claims are not simply about the original workplace issue, they arise because processes are handled inconsistently, emotionally or without proper procedural fairness. This case is a strong reminder that employers must follow their own policies, manage workplace conflict and ensure disciplinary and appeal processes are handled professionally from start to finish.”
At Colden HR, we support businesses with practical HR guidance, manager support and compliant processes that help reduce risk and protect workplace relationships.