31/12/2025
Thoughts:
Was it that the Indigenous societies were civilized and the Europeans who were barbarians?
The short answer:
Many Indigenous societies were highly civilized by any serious definition of civilization and European colonizers often behaved with extreme brutality that contradicted their own moral claims.
1-But civilization is not a racial trait, and barbarism is not exclusive to Europe.
What Indigenous civilizations actually were
Across the Americas, Africa, Asia, and Oceania, many societies had:
• Sophisticated governance systems
• Environmental sustainability practices that lasted thousands of years
• Deep philosophical and spiritual traditions
• Complex trade networks
• Non-carceral conflict resolution systems
Examples:
• Andean societies managed ecosystems at altitude with precision agriculture.
• Caribbean and Amazonian peoples practiced forest cultivation, not “primitive wandering.”
• Many North American nations had confederacies with checks and balances.
• Asian civilizations had bureaucratic states when much of Europe was feudal.
By their own contexts, many were deeply civilized.
What European colonization actually was
Colonization involved:
• Mass killing
• Forced labor
• Cultural destruction
• Resource extraction
• Slavery justified through pseudo-science and theology
This behavior violated the very Christian, Enlightenment, and legal values Europeans claimed to represent.
So yes, the conduct of colonization was profoundly uncivilized, even by Europe’s own standards.
2. Does that mean Europeans are “genetically warlike” or “undeveloped”?
There is no credible scientific evidence that any group of humans is genetically more violent, more demonic, or less developed. (But it sure seems that way if you pay attention to US leadership and Eastern compatriots.)
Violence is:
• Structural
• Institutional
• Political
• Economic
Not genetic, many Europeans descendants are not violent, for example, all of Canada, and some Scandinavian countries. Most are highly intelligent with zero violent tendencies.
If we accept genetic explanations, we unintentionally:
• Validate racial determinism
• Mirror the logic used to enslave Africans
• Turn moral responsibility into biology (which absolves systems of blame)
That’s a trap.
3. Then why does violence concentrate in certain groups today, particularly people from the US and EU?
Colonization created violent conditions.
For enslaved Africans:
• Families were deliberately broken
• Cultural memory was erased
• Languages destroyed
• Trauma normalized
• Survival required adaptation to brutality
This produces intergenerational trauma.
For colonized Indigenous peoples:
• Social structures were dismantled
• Leadership assassinated
• Economies destroyed
• Identity criminalized
When violence appears later, it is often:
• Displaced
• Internalized
• Recycled downward
4. What about modern imperial violence?
the contradiction:
Those who:
• Speak of “human rights”
• Claim moral authority
• Use words like “development,” “stability,” and “security”
Are often the same actors who:
• Bomb civilian infrastructure
• Overthrow governments
• Extract resources, stealing other peoples oil.
• Impose sanctions that starve populations
This isn’t accidental.
It reflects what scholars call:
• Imperial continuity
• Structural violence
• Technocratic barbarism
The violence is:
• Cleaned up linguistically
• Outsourced institutionally
• Abstracted bureaucratically
Which makes it feel less savage, but arguably more dangerous.
5. Were we lied to about “civilization”?
In many ways, yes.
The dominant global narrative equated:
• Technology = morality
• Wealth = virtue
• Power = progress
History shows this is false.
Civilization should be measured by:
• How societies treat the vulnerable
• Whether they can coexist without annihilation
• Whether power is restrained
• Whether life is sacred beyond rhetoric
By those measures, many ancient and Indigenous societies outperform modern empires.
6. But here is the crucial warning
The conclusion:
“They are monsters, demons, or inherently evil.”
But That path leads to:
• Moral absolutism
• Dehumanization
• Cycles of revenge
• The same logic colonizers used
The danger is who they are.
The danger is systems that reward domination, extraction, and impunity.
Those systems can possess any people but these people are particularly good at it.
7. Conclusion: Be like Wakanda:
• Cultural protection
• Economic self-determination
• Community resilience
• Refusal to be exploited
These are valid goals.
Selective engagement, cultural sovereignty, economic independence, and narrative control
Stay invisible, don’t trade with them, let thier societies collapse with low birth rates, bad food and expensive healthcare. Don’t buy from them. Grow your own food. Get your medicine from India. Your energy from Trinidad, visit Dubai instead of the big apple.