11/03/2022
Let's talk about tree's. (Seriously, lets talk. I'd love a discussion from backyard riders to Master Saddlers.)
More specifically, let's talk about "testing" tree's to see if they're damaged or broken.
And even more specifically, my target audience is for the people doing their absolute best to fold saddles in half.
I have been sent a hundred video's & photo's over the years of people flexing, showing off their core strength, and doing a very impressive job of trying to get the pommel to touch the cantle. One memorable photo sent was of a saddle sitting on the barn floor, pommel down so the saddle is sitting on it's nose, with a person sitting on the cantle.
These are all supposedly evidence of tree's being broken.
I'm alarmed by most of these ... because if the tree wasn't damaged before it sure might be now.
People, please stop doing this. A quick, gentle flex is fine. But all you fine folks determined to make origami out of a saddle, please just stop.
If you truly have a suspicion a tree is damaged, then send it to a bench saddler who can drop the panels, do a visual inspection and accurately test the tree.
I replace broken tree's every week; different brands, models, disciplines. I'm sure there are plenty of other bench saddlers & master saddlers that also replace broken tree's, they can likely back up these statistics ...
The vast majority of tree damage or a break is in the head of the tree. It's not even in the seat/rails.
In my shop, I'd say 90% are broken in the head.
8% in the rails.
2% a variety of other random & bizarre breaks.
I have a shelf full of broken & damaged tree's that I've held onto because they were a really interesting break, or the story of how it was broken was interesting. I have tree's that were welded and broken again. Wood tree's & synthetic tree's.
I think 1 of them is actually broken in the rails. And it literally is folded in half, 2 separate pieces. The seat leather was the only thing holding it together.
The seat & rails of the tree are flexible on purpose, they're spring tree's. The wood of the tree is laminated layers of wood, glued & pressed together. This gives the wood flexibility while maintaining structure & integrity.
Then there is flat piece of tempered steel running from pommel to cantle. This steel is incredibly strong, but not 100% resistant to damage or complete failure. However, when it fails it almost always snaps completely through. That's the nature of "tempering" it.
Between the flexibility of the wood and steel, it's designed to absorb the landing weight of the rider. "Landing weight" from either a sitting trot, 3' jump, etc.
It's a shock absorber, as is the wool in the panels, the horse's spine & hocks, and also the riders hips & knee's ~ you get the picture. These shock absorbers are supposed to work in harmony, when 1 starts to fail the others take up the load.
And just like a person's knee's start to wear out, so too can a tree.
So when I see someone hyper flexing the tempered steel & wood rails of a spring tree ... it makes my knee's & heart scream.
Slightly different for synthetic tree's, due to a lack of laminated wood & tempered steel spring rails, but the same principle applies. They've been tested to flex in all the right places and be rigid where it counts.
Some synthetic tree's are more flexible than others, synthetic can actually be very rigid ~ some of the more rigid tree's on the market ~ to actually being some of the more flexible tree's on the market. They can still break, but usually when they break it's obnoxiously obvious.
I applaud people for wanting to test their saddle to be sure it's not compromised or damaged in any way. I've built a career around this. But for the love of your saddle, please just chill when it comes to testing the rails of the tree. There is not a world where tree's are supposed to be folded in half. Please stop making me clutch my pearls.
Thank you!