Judgment Index

10/13/2026

Part 5 of the Hartman-Parton Paradigm: Know Who You Are Beneath the Surface

The hair. The rhinestones. The clothes. The personality.
Dolly Parton created one of the most recognizable public images in entertainment. But image and identity are not the same thing. And that distinction takes me straight back to Hartman.

Who are you when we take away the job title? We know how to describe our responsibilities. Hartman’s emphasis on Self-awareness asks us to look more deeply at the unique person beneath those roles.
One danger he explored was becoming what we call outwardly led.

That happens when roles, expectations, rewards, pressure or approval begin to have too much influence over how we define and value ourselves.
Dolly has spoken about knowing her own nature, understanding her strengths and weaknesses, and protecting her identity rather than giving it away to someone else.
It brings us to a very practical question:
Am I defining myself, or am I allowing the world around me to do it for me?

Our roles matter. So do our responsibilities to other people. The challenge is recognizing when those things have become the primary measure of our worth.

Before we decide what to do with our lives, we first have to understand who is doing the living.
Which parts of how you describe yourself reflect what matters to you, and which reflect what others expect of you?

Next: Hartman’s progression from knowing yourself to choosing, creating and giving of yourself.
-MBB
Read the full story on AXIOLOGY by JI: https://axiologybyji.com/2026/09/19/hartman-parton-paradigm-axiology-human-value/

10/06/2026

Part 4 of the Hartman-Parton Paradigm: You Still Have to Do the Work

There is a danger when we start talking about purpose, human value and making a difference. It can all begin to sound a little lofty.
But somebody still has to do the work.

Robert S. Hartman’s life required enormous effort and reinvention. He fled fascism, rebuilt his life, taught, wrote and continued developing formal axiology.
Dolly Parton likewise spent decades writing, recording, touring, performing, building businesses and supporting causes that mattered to her.
Their work was very different. Both lives remind us that meaningful ideas require practical effort.

In Judgment Index language, that get-it-done side is a large part of the Extrinsic dimension. It involves function, performance and putting something into action in the real world.
The book still has to reach the child. The plan still has to become something people can use.
But there is another question worth asking along the way.
How much of your identity has become tied to what you accomplish?

Work gives us opportunities to develop our abilities and contribute. It can also begin to carry too much weight in how we define and value ourselves.
If a project fails, a role changes or a busy season ends, do we still recognize the person underneath it all?
Purpose requires effort. Self-awareness helps us understand both what we are working toward and who is doing the work.

What are you working hard to accomplish, and how much of your sense of worth depends on the outcome?

Next: knowing who you are beneath the surface.
-MBB
Read the full story on AXIOLOGY by JI: https://axiologybyji.com/2026/09/19/hartman-parton-paradigm-axiology-human-value/

10/03/2026

Part 3 of the Hartman-Parton Paradigm: When Caring Becomes Impact

Caring about someone matters. What happens when that caring becomes something you can actually do?
Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library offers a useful example.

Dolly has spoken about her father’s inability to read and write as the personal inspiration behind her commitment to children’s literacy. She launched the Imagination Library in 1995 for children in her home county, and it eventually expanded internationally.
Sometimes the contribution is recognizing a need, understanding what you can do about it and finding a way to extend the impact. Through a Hartman lens, we can see several kinds of value working together.

There is the Person: an individual child whose life may be changed by developing a love of reading.
There is the Work: choosing books, raising money, organizing distribution and getting those books into children’s hands.
There is the larger System: building something capable of reaching beyond one child, one family or one community.
Intrinsic helps us recognize the unique person and the meaning involved. Extrinsic helps us consider what needs to be done and how effectively we can do it. Systemic helps us see structure, possibilities and the larger impact.
We need all three.

Caring without action may accomplish very little. Getting things done without remembering the person can become mechanical. Working hard without considering the bigger picture can leave us busy without moving in the best direction.

Good judgment requires us to see more than one kind of value.
Think about something you are working on. Are you giving enough attention to the person, the work and the bigger picture?

Next: purpose still requires somebody to do the work.
-MBB
Read the full story on AXIOLOGY by JI: https://axiologybyji.com/2026/09/19/hartman-parton-paradigm-axiology-human-value/

09/28/2026

Part 2 of the Hartman-Parton Paradigm: What Makes Something Valuable?

A coat can be worth very little. Or it can be priceless.
Think about Dolly Parton’s Coat of Many Colors. Her mother made it from simple materials. It had a practical job to do: keep a child warm.
But that wasn’t what made the coat truly valuable to Dolly. Its deeper value came from who made it, why she made it and the love attached to it.
That story gives us a simple way to understand three dimensions in Robert S. Hartman’s axiology.

Systemic: The Idea
We have a concept of what a coat is. This dimension deals with concepts, rules, structure and ideas.

Extrinsic: The Function
Does it fit? Is it warm? Is it well made? This dimension considers usefulness, performance and comparison in the real world.

Intrinsic: The Unique
This was her coat, made by her mother. Its meaning could never be adequately measured by the price of the fabric. This dimension recognizes uniqueness.

Now think about how we see people.
We know their titles. We know what they do. We may know how well they perform. All of that matters, but it does not completely explain the value of the person.

The same is true of you.
Your roles and abilities are important parts of your life. Recognizing your unique Self asks you to see more than the functions you perform.

Who in your life might you understand differently if you looked beyond their role?

Next: how these three dimensions can work together to turn caring into impact.
-MBB
Read the full story on AXIOLOGY by JI: https://axiologybyji.com/2026/09/19/hartman-parton-paradigm-axiology-human-value/

09/19/2026

The Hartman-Parton Paradigm

Two Remarkably Different Lives. A Shared Lesson in Human Value. What could a philosopher who devoted his life to understanding human value possibly have in common with Dolly Parton? More than you might think. Robert S. Hartman was a philosopher, scholar and pioneer in formal axiology, the study of value and how we make value judgments. Dolly Parton built an extraordinary life through music, storytelling, business and philanthropy....

Discover the unexpected connection between Robert S. Hartman and Dolly Parton through axiology, human value, Self-awareness and purposeful living.