08/27/2026
Most hiring teams think their process is working. Candidates apply -> Recruiters screen them -> Interviews happen -> Someone gets an offer ->The role gets filled.
But filling a role just means you have a functioning process. It doesn't necessarily mean you have a great one.
So what actually makes a hiring process good?
We put together a list of 9 signs that can tell you, based on research from SHRM, OPM, Harvard Business Review, and LinkedIn Talent Solutions.
Some are obvious, others are easy to overlook:
✅ Are interviewers actually documenting evidence from interviews, or just going with their overall impression?
✅ Can candidates easily tell what happens next, or do they have to email someone to find out?
✅ Are you moving candidates through the process quickly, or are they sitting in limbo between steps?
We turned the 9 signs into a quick self-assessment. Give yourself a point for every one that's true of your hiring process:
- 8-9: You're doing a lot right
- 5-7: Solid foundation, but there are probably a few places to improve
- 0-4: There may be more opportunity in your process than in finding more candidates
See how your hiring process stacks up and take the assessment here:
Most hiring processes just get positions filled. Here's how to tell if yours actually works, backed by SHRM, OPM, Harvard Business Review, and LinkedIn Talent Solutions research.