06/07/2022
Ways to Engage a Dissatisfied Employee
Good employees – sometimes even your best employees – are handing in resignation letters frequently these days. Convention wisdom says to “bribe” these employees to stay by offering bigger paychecks and better perks, but if your business cannot afford to do these things, what do you do?
The truth is that bigger paychecks and better perks may hold off the resignation for a period of time – typically six months to a year – but those are not the keys to keeping your employees if they are dissatisfied with their jobs. Just 38.2% of workers aged 25-45 say that pay is the most important factor in their job satisfaction.
In 2021 and 2022, mid-career employees (30-45 yrs old) resigned at a rate 20% higher than in 2020. But this worker dissatisfaction started long before the pandemic. It seems that the pandemic just gave workers the opportunity to make the move to leave the jobs they no longer like.
What employees want more than anything else is work that inspires them and creates harmony between who they are and what they do. When they are inspired, they are more engaged, more productive, and more loyal. Employees want to feel like they are working toward something larger than themselves, understand how their day-to-day job makes that happen, and have autonomy to shape their role in it all.
I was one of these dissatisfied workers. I stayed with a company that treated me poorly, limited advancement, and paid well below market value simply because I felt like our agency was making a difference in the lives of people. When that agency started to make it clear that the people we served were nothing more than money for the agency, I wanted nothing more than to leave and go somewhere else. Suddenly the 10-18 hour days, the requests for assistance while I was on PTO, and the constant need for me to handle situations for others was no longer balanced by making a difference. So what could my employer have done to keep me there?
They could have created a way for me to have a better work-life balance and to have a work-life alignment. I don’t mind working long hours if it means something, but it matters how much the work detracts form the time that employees spend away from it too. In a recent poll from SHRM, 65% of workers wanted to have more control over the teams to which they were assigned, the projects on which they worked, and their ability to influence hours or earnings. While one would expect to see workers gain more control as they risk through the ranks, the opposite is true for women in particular. The higher the rank of a woman, the more likely she had less control over her work and her work-life balance. This causes women like me to leave the workforce at higher numbers than their male counterparts.
Ask your employees how the work they do each day allows them to achieve the career advancement the seek, nurture their families, or manifests their values on a daily basis. If they have pain points where their work is counter to these things, it gives you a place to start to address their dissatisfaction.
The biggest deficit seen in the recent poll was the employees’ relationships with their leaders. Almost all workers said they want to work for a leader who inspired them, but only 36% said they actually do. Investing in your relationship with your employees is one to bridge the divide and unlock their motivation. Take time to find out what brought the employee to the job, what energizes them, and what excites them about your company. This will deepen your understanding of what inspires them so that you, in turn, can better create a connection for them between the company’s work and their personal needs in the future.
Incorporate your current employees in recruiting efforts. Managers should ask current employees if the vacated position is still needed and if the job description is still relevant. Ask for their help improving it or filling gaps on the current team. This process has both external and internal benefits. Position descriptions are scanned by employees, and a great job description connects the position’s responsibilities to your organization’s purpose. Reading it will help your current staff rekindle the excitement that brought them to your organization and will remind them of how their day-to-day work fits into the bigger picture.
92.4% of respondents reported that they do better work when they see how the quality of their work matters in the big picture. Rather than simply passing on organizational imperatives, how can you connect the dots for team members who wonder, “How does this affect or benefit me?” Help employees see the connection between their day-to-day and the long-term goals of the company.
Rather than letting your best workers consider resignation, offer them an alternative and personally compelling path. By giving people more agency, re-engaging them, and re-inspiring them, you can create work environments that help them feel like the best versions of themselves. When this happens, they reinvest themselves into their organizations and amplify their own team-building behaviors. Instead of job searching and resigning, they’ll be there with renewed dedication, increased investment, and elevated energy.