04/26/2026
I know what you’re thinking…
Who in the world keeps performance reviews from 40 years ago?
This guy right here does.
I keep all of my old performance reviews, training documents, and notes from my early days in the restaurant business, and it reminds me of something I believe we need to revive in our industry:
Real feedback.
Personal feedback.
Intentional feedback.
One-on-one feedback.
Throughout my career, feedback mattered deeply to me. It was rarely just about the compensation. It was about knowing where I stood. Was I meeting the goal? Was I exceeding expectations? Was I growing? Was I becoming the kind of leader I wanted to become?
And I think that matters more than we sometimes realize.
Look, you will not find a bigger proponent of technology than me. Technology has made our business faster, smarter, and more efficient. But with all of the tools, dashboards, apps, systems, and platforms we use today, we have to be careful that we do not lose the human side of leadership.
Because our people still deserve to know where they stand.
I will never forget something I said when I first joined Chipotle. We were in a meeting with Cathy Nanneman and the training team, and the subject of performance reviews came up. I said then, and I still believe it today:
No one should ever be surprised by the rating they receive in a performance review.
Not one person.
The only way that happens is if feedback is happening consistently throughout the year. Not once a year. Not only when something goes wrong. Not only when someone is already frustrated or checked out.
Feedback should be ongoing.
I had a boss at Chipotle, Matt Scheiman, who was excellent at this. When I was a multi-unit leader working for Matt, he would regularly ask us:
“If the quarter ended today, how would you rate yourself, and why?”
That always stuck with me.
It forced me to reflect. It forced me to calibrate. It forced me to think honestly about my own performance before anyone else gave me a score.
And because Matt had those conversations with us throughout the year, the actual performance review was never a surprise. It was just a conversation.
And that is what a performance review should be.
Not a high-stress, drawn-out, awkward meeting.
It should be a conversation about:
Where are you today?
What goals did you hit?
Where did you fall short?
What are you proud of?
Where do you want to go?
And how can I help you get there?
That is leadership.
So here is my challenge to every restaurant and hospitality leader reading this:
Do not shortchange your team on feedback.
Give them the feedback they are craving. Let them know where they stand. Help them understand what they need to work on. Celebrate their wins. Call out their growth. Ask them where they want to go.
And then help them get there.
Because feedback, when done right, can create opportunities for people that otherwise wouldn't exist.