09/01/2022
With the average victory margin being 21 points with 4 teams in the College Football Playoff, what is the competitive point of expanding the playoff format to 12 teams???
There is no competitive point to it whatsoever.
As always in sports at every level, it's all about the Almighty Dollar.
In college football, there is usually only one or two teams worthy of hoisting the crystal football in early January - and frequently there is only one team.
The BCS was a flat-out joke! The best team was almost always chosen for the "championship game." Rarely, if ever (off the top of my head), was the second-best team chosen. My favorite (sarcasm warning) BCS Championship game was in 2014 when #1 Alabama clobbered Notre Dame, 42-14.
The Diamond Rankings for 2012 had Bama as the clear #1 (a Diamond Rankings measure of 97.44) and ND as no better than #4 (a DR measure of 91.74; with an SEM of ~4.80) despite being 12-0. In ND's last regular season game against Pitt, it took them going to OT against a .500 team to eke out a victory. Notre Dame had NO business in that game. With a difference in measures of 5.70, combined with a standard error of measurement (SEM) of ~4.80, ND never had a chance unless they played a perfect game and Alabama played horribly.
Expanding the playoffs to 12 teams will result in a lot of playoff games looking like this Crimson Tide vs. Golden Dome match-up from the 2013 BCS Championship game (for the 2012 season).
If you ever want to understand almost anything, follow the money, and then you'll understand. That's the only possible explanation for expanding the CFP.