05/26/2026
π LOLLY'S STEWARDSHIP LESSON #4 π
Okay, you've thanked them. You've kept them engaged. Now the question everyone asks:
"When can I ask them to give AGAIN?"
Here's the truth: There's no magic timeline. But there ARE signs they're ready.
SIGNS A DONOR IS READY FOR ANOTHER ASK:
β
They're engaging with your updates (opening emails, commenting on posts)
β
They've asked questions about the project
β
They've introduced you to someone else
β
They've mentioned wanting to help more
β
Enough time has passed that you've SHOWN impact from their last gift
WHEN TO ASK AGAIN:
β After you've delivered on what you promised with their first gift
β When you have a NEW, specific need (not the same vague "support our mission")
β When you've communicated 3-5 times WITHOUT asking
HOW TO ASK:
"Your $250 last quarter helped us [specific outcome]. We're now at the stage where [new need]. Would you consider supporting this next phase with [specific amount]?"
Make it personal. Make it specific. Make it about THEIR continued impact.
That's the stewardship cycle: Thank β Engage β Report β Ask β Repeat.
Master this, and you'll never struggle with donor retention again. π¦π