08/24/2026
⏰Ready For An Alarming Result? Pay Attention To This One!⏰
I just analyzed 225 indexes from a current indexed annuity index report. 85% of them are Volatility-Controlled Indexes.
VCI's are designed normally with some type of equity index internally, but also have a rebalancing metric internally to push more weighting into cash or bonds to control overall swings in options cost... not necessarily increase returns, or even risk adjusted return.
This can reduce the price of the option and come with big participation rates or caps that look great in an illustration... but doesn't actually move the return needle in a better position... quite the opposite.
And these things are BABIES. 54% launched in the last 5 years. A third launched in the last 3. Only 19% have 10+ years of real, live history.
- This means any product using them is showing a back-casted return sequence that is essentially a guess as to what the investment bank offering THINKS it would have done.
I broke all 225 into 2 categories:
1. Equity Indexes
2. Volatility Controlled Indexes
Ready for some insane results?
Last 1 year average:
- Equity Indexes -> 23.3%
- VC Indexes -> 4.6%
Last 5 year average:
- Equity Indexes -> 8.9%
- VC Indexes -> 1.7%
Since inception average:
- Equity Indexes -> 8.5%
- VC Indexes -> 3.2%
Wow... no wonder policy holders are pi**ed off at their crappy performance when the market has been killing it.
So why do agents/advisors use these?
A VCI can come with a participation rate of 100%-200% on average.
That sales pitch looks like this:
"If the index makes 10%, you make 20%" ... but in reality they are getting 200% of 1.7%, when cap rates on equity indexes are 8% - 12%, and some equity indexes coming with par rates of 50% to 90%.
Don't be fooled... stick to equities inside of FIA's & RILA's.
If you want more analysis like this, hop over to www.theannuitygiants.com and check out our memberships.
- $99/mo for EVERYTHING.
No Contracts Required
No Recruiting
No Long Term Commitments
(only month to month unless you want the 1yr discount)
Use code "AG2026" at checkout for a FREE 30-day trial!