02/16/2026
Island Lesson #2.
“Reimagining the Church's Bottom Line"
In many religious circles, the word "profit" is often met with skepticism, even disdain. The assumption is that the pursuit of wealth is antithetical to spiritual values, that the church should exist solely on the fringes of society, detached from the practicalities of business. But is this mindset serving the greater good, or is it hindering the church's ability to make a meaningful impact?
As I've reflected on my upbringing in the Anglican and Methodist traditions, I recall pastors living modestly, often struggling to make ends meet. But in a conversation with a young evangelical pastor, I was struck by a different paradigm. He was part of a global church with a clear mission: grow, expand, and empower. His lifestyle, while comfortable, was not the point – the focus was on building a thriving community that served others.
This got me thinking: isn't the church, in its own way, a business? One that requires investment, strategic planning, and effective leadership to deliver value to its stakeholders? The value proposition is clear: spiritual growth, community connection, life purpose, and practical support. The church solves real problems – loneliness, lack of meaning, generic faith, and more. And it promises transformation through authentic relationships and relevant teachings.
The church is not a business in the traditional sense, but it can learn from business principles. Take the pastor I spoke with – his approach was entrepreneurial, innovative, and outward-focused. He understood that to make a difference, he needed to be supported, resourced, and empowered to take risks.
Perhaps it's time to reframe our thinking: profit, in the context of the church, is not about accumulating wealth, but about creating value, investing in people, and advancing a mission that transforms lives. By embracing this mindset, the church can become a more effective, impactful, and relevant force in the modern world.
Ultimately, it's time for the church to shed its discomfort with the concept of "profit" and recognize that true spiritual growth and community impact require strategic investment, innovative thinking, and a willingness to thrive.
Drawn from eight decades of island life, an early glimpse into my forthcoming memoir — coming soon.