10/06/2026
A client I had for years always led with their best and final. No dance, no back and forth, just the number they actually meant on the very first pass, and I put a disclaimer on every single offer I presented for them. This is their best and final. There is no negotiating this one. I wanted every candidate to hear it from me before they heard the number, so nobody walked into it blind, and most of them took it as intended.
One of them countered anyway. A Senior Director of Human Resources, and I honestly cannot remember what she asked for. It wasn't much more than what was on the table; I know that.
As a recruiter, you can only control somebody so much, and if they want us to go back and negotiate, then we go back and negotiate.
The client pulled the offer.
I will never forget it, because she did not expect it. Nobody in that room expected it.
For a long time, I thought that client was in the wrong. I don't even know where I picked up the idea that leading with your best number was wrong, but I believed it for years, and then I watched it work. There is something almost kind about a company telling you exactly where you stand on the first pass instead of making you guess your way toward it.
So, when an offer comes, ask the person handing it to you which kind you are holding. Some of them have room in them. A few really don't.