All-Star Cookies

All-Star Cookies Baking has become a passion of mine. I’m a mom and a teacher, trying to make a little extra money.

There aren’t many people I’ll make OU cookies for, but this girl is definitely one of them! Congrats, Lilli! I’m so prou...
05/24/2026

There aren’t many people I’ll make OU cookies for, but this girl is definitely one of them! Congrats, Lilli! I’m so proud of you, Super Star! 🤩⭐️

Peep the girls taking a selfie of themselves when I asked them to take our picture. 😂

Graduation cookies are in full swing! The first 2 sets of OSU grad cookies went out the door this morning!
05/08/2026

Graduation cookies are in full swing! The first 2 sets of OSU grad cookies went out the door this morning!

I was honored to get to make these gluten-free cookies for a book launch yesterday. I have had all 3 of Joslin’s oldest ...
04/01/2026

I was honored to get to make these gluten-free cookies for a book launch yesterday. I have had all 3 of Joslin’s oldest kiddos in my class(the third is currently in my class), so I’ve been hearing about this book for a LONG time! I can’t wait to read it, and I think you should check it out, too!

Sometimes people have more faith in me than I have in myself. I think I’ve actually said that about this particular cust...
03/24/2026

Sometimes people have more faith in me than I have in myself. I think I’ve actually said that about this particular customer, in fact. I was already nervous about these ADORABLE cookies… then my projector wouldn’t work, so I ended up having to completely free-hand ALL of them. 😳
After lots of stressing and trying to figure out a way around it, I just went for it…. The fist picture was my inspiration picture, the second is what I made.
(She requested coral, instead of the burnt orange.)

I had to ask everyone in the house before accepting it, but I think they turned out pretty okay! 🤣

Bow cookies for a sweet Super Star of mine for her birthday!
03/24/2026

Bow cookies for a sweet Super Star of mine for her birthday!

I’m BAAAAAaaack!!! This weekend, I made my very first set of cookies since December, and my very first set of cookies in...
03/16/2026

I’m BAAAAAaaack!!!

This weekend, I made my very first set of cookies since December, and my very first set of cookies in our new house!

This week, I will be making the last set of cookies until after February. I *might* be available for a few Valentine’s D...
01/02/2026

This week, I will be making the last set of cookies until after February. I *might* be available for a few Valentine’s Day orders, but I’ll have to play it by ear. I’ve got some big things coming up, and won’t have any extra time for cookies. I’ll be sure to let everyone know when I’m back up and running with cookies!

These sweet Christmas themed baby shower cookies went out last week.
12/23/2025

These sweet Christmas themed baby shower cookies went out last week.

❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️Back by popular demand… I will be offering snowflake cookies again this year! If you n...
11/30/2025

❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️

Back by popular demand… I will be offering snowflake cookies again this year! If you need to take a treat to a party, want something yummy over the holidays, or just want some cookies for yourself, I’ve got you covered!

Snowflake cookies- $40 per dozen

❄️The first order of snowflake cookies are going out the door today! ❄️

I haven’t advertised for Thanksgiving cookies, because I wasn’t sure how many I would have the time/energy to make this ...
11/21/2025

I haven’t advertised for Thanksgiving cookies, because I wasn’t sure how many I would have the time/energy to make this year. If you’re looking for a cute and yummy treat to bring to Thanksgiving, I’ve got you covered!

Pumpkin cookies- $40 per dozen

Limited amount this year.

Address

5022 W 4th Avenue
Stillwater, OK
74074

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when All-Star Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category