05/30/2026
I want to tell you about Garrett.
Garrett was a crew leader at Callahan's Lawn Care. Solid guy. Good worker. Under straight hourly — he was reliable, consistent, and completely disengaged from the financial performance of his route.
Then we installed pay for performance.
A few weeks in, Garrett came to me with a number.
He had calculated that stopping at Dunkin Donuts every morning was costing him between $1,200 and $1,500 per year in lost bonus. He had done the math himself. The stop cost about 12 to 15 minutes. Over a full season, factoring in the jobs he could complete in that time and his share of the savings — he had worked it out to the dollar.
Under straight hourly — that morning stop cost him nothing. It was just part of the morning. His pay was the same either way.
Under pay for performance — that stop cost him real money. And he had stopped stopping.
I did not tell Garrett to stop. His crew leader meeting was not about Dunkin Donuts. He figured it out on his own because the incentive structure made it worth figuring out.
That is the culture shift that nobody talks about when they sell you on P4P as a compensation strategy.
The crews start running the route like they own it. Not because you told them to. Because they have a financial reason to.
The people who stay under P4P are your production-minded crew members. The ones who were carrying the people who were just running out the clock under straight hourly. They thrive. And the ones who were coasting — they find somewhere else to go. Without you having to push them out.
That is the culture that P4P builds when the foundation under it is right.
Comment SYSTEM below to see how pay for performance is built inside the Lawn Care Operating System.
— Mike Callahan · SimpleGrowth Systems