22/01/2024
Is emotion the bee-all of marketing?
Ethan Hayes was stung to death by a swarm of African honeybees in his backyard on the afternoon of 27th February 2017. A New Year’s resolution to reconcile with his half-brother died tragically with him.
Despite a lifelong hymenopteran venom allergy, Ethan made no attempt to evade the dark, angry thousand-bee cloud protesting his overzealous summer pruning. Was it a sense of invincibility, ignorance, or a death wish that killed Hayes? As it turns out, none of the above.
Ethan Hayes was incapable of emotion. A car accident a few years earlier damaged the amygdala in Ethan's temporal lobe, impairing his ability to recall associated memory and emotions critical to mental information processing, decision-making, and reaction. Despite available rational data, Ethan's faulty emotional system failed to cognitively link an obviously angry crowd of bees to a range of predictable consequences and appropriate response options. And the disconnect proved fatal.
Surprisingly, most marketing and selling messages die a Hayes-like death all the time. Not because entire audiences suffer from emotional system damage like Ethan's. But because many organisations seemingly assume they do.
Research shows that over 70% of marketing and selling messages fail to use the right emotional code. So, all those messages flatline on the spot, suffocating precious investment, killing brands, and bleeding shareholder value and confidence fast.
Despite clear neuroscientific proof that all information gets processed by the brain’s subconscious system first and 95% of all human decisions form emotionally, most efforts to persuade continue to aim at the conscious rational mind. But because logic and raw facts and figures are incongruent with the brain’s primary processing chemistry, rationally led messages carry low vital signs. And go into cardiac arrest in seconds.
Messaging the same way and expecting a different result is classic insanity. Shifts in messaging design are certainly needed to resuscitate marketing’s ailing affect. But change requires a conviction that the neurology works, and an acquisition of application know-how. To put the science to work for your business, here’s some basic stuff you need to know and apply - before your rivals do.
Survival, the brain’s core function, requires the 22-watt human mind to process eleven million bits of data per second. Or risk the chance of a surprise death. To manage its huge and critical workload on extremely limited battery power, the brain has necessarily evolved a lightning-fast and automated production line to scan everything in a heartbeat. Situated in the subconscious, the sophisticated system uses reflex to gauge what deserves scarce electricity - and which reactions to emote to realise gain or avoid threat. The subconscious is always the first responder to any stimuli. And it calls all the shots.
Emotion is the chemistry component of the brain's governing subconscious reaction system. Its neurotransmissions play a crucial role in sensing and signalling nuances in data, retrieving the most useful associative memory set to interpret it - and snapping best fit reaction plans to the stimuli in an instant. Messages without clear emotional cues make it difficult for the brain to blend the right chemistry needed to trigger a motor response. Stories without strong and familiar feeling paralyse on the spot.
Note. The word emotion is derived from the Latin ‘’movere’’ meaning to stir up, agitate or action. The root of the word helps to appreciate the function of emotion in the human decision making workflow.
Research work by Christopher Morin, Ph.D., and Patrick Renvoise, identified three key workflows the subconscious emotional system uses to interpret and react to sensory inputs. These will help marketers to design and structure the kind of emotive messages that engage and influence minds more effectively. They are:
•Emotional valence: The brain's subconscious reaction system instantly searches for directional cues that help determine whether to move towards, away, or against stimuli - and how strong and fast the reaction needs to be. Messages that make it clear whether information requires positive or negative chemistry save the brain scarce energy. Messages with clear valence go right to the front of the cognitive queue.
Application example. Positive valence: “Grow your wealth with confidence. Our expert strategies pave the way for financial prosperity and a secure future." Negative valence: "Protect your hard-earned wealth. Our guidance shields you from financial loss, navigating uncertainties and minimising risks."
•Emotional utility: The emotional system also immediately evaluates every input to check that a payback on energy invested in any reaction exceeds its cost. Messages with an obvious, immediate, and personally relevant yield are most likely to get an electricity allocation, emotional chemistry, and fast engagement.
Application example: “Our service offers 5 ways to foolproof the protection and growth of your money."
•Emotional encoding: Memories and emotions get encoded together. Memories linked to stronger emotions get recalled (and stored) faster. Strong cues in a message help the energy-challenged brain to retrieve specific associative memory, interpret data, and reflexively select a reaction pattern more easily. Different language and other sensory cue options cause the brain to form different recall paths that trigger different emotional chemistry. Messages that deliberately apply specific and useful mental cues are most likely to get cognitive traction.
Application example: "Plant the seeds of your financial success in our fertile fields. We’ll nurture them. You watch your wealth blossom."
Robert Plutchik, the professor emeritus at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in the USA, developed a psycho-evolutionary theory of emotion and a wheel of emotion framework that will help you to breathe emotional vitality into your brand narratives. The psychological framework represents the eight primary emotions the human emotional system uses, and their relationship with an estimated thirty-four thousand sub-emotions that branch from them. Search for Plutchik's emotion design wheel to get more information. Or ask me.
Modern neuroscience is clear. To engage and influence the human mind effectively, aim your marketing and selling messages at the emotional reaction system beneath the conscious surface of the brain. Don’t, and the marketing results you get will be sure to sting.
References.
Emotional. Leonard Mlodinow.
The persuasion code. Christopher Morin and Patrick Renvoise.
Emotions and life. Robert Plutchick.
About Jonathan Hall. I am a neuromarketer and the writer of this ''Short story'' blog. I blend more than 35 years of marketing and brand strategy expertise with applied behavioural science know-how to solve clients brand narrative, messaging, and mind influence problems. I have authored two neuromarketing reference books, ''The power of BrandStory" and ''BrainSell" and developed an easy-to-apply neuro messaging framework. Results from my work have earned many accolades including the IMM Industrial Marketing Company of the Year, a PSA Innovator of the Year Finalist, and a Deloitte Champion award. I am the founder and CEO of FuseWorks, ThinkWorks and BrandStory. My neuromarketing group of companies, established in 1997, is based in Sandton, South Africa.
The short story puts the most useful behavioural science research in your inbox. Please share if you like this.
For expert help: www.brandstory.co.za | [email protected] | +27 83 251 0716