Winelands Consulting

Directions Website

Winelands Consulting We will manage all your HR and Labour related requirements in the work environment.

05/11/2026
Ons gewaardeerde klient brei hul besigheid uit.SLEGS aansoeke wat per epos I gestuur word, sal oorweeg word.Ons klient b...
26/10/2026

Ons gewaardeerde klient brei hul besigheid uit.

SLEGS aansoeke wat per epos I gestuur word, sal oorweeg word.

Ons klient behou hul reg voor om geen aanstelling te maak nie. Indien u geen reaksie op u aansoek ontvang binne 2 weke na sluiting van die aansoeke nie, was u aansoek onsuksesvol.

Fair procedure in misconduct of employees are key!!!
24/10/2026

Fair procedure in misconduct of employees are key!!!

National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa & others v Allens Meshco (Pty) Ltd [2026] ZALCCT 183 Get link Facebook X Pinterest Email Other Apps By AJ Nel Date of Judgment & Seat of Court: 20 October 2026, Labour Court, Cape TownCase No: C291/2024Name of Judge(s): Lagrange JSummary of Factual Matr...

24/10/2026

FORM OVER SUBSTANCE: CAN THE CCMA FIX A MISCLASSIFIED DISMISSAL?

In Dawn Ltd and Others v Molefe and Others (Case No: JR 2114/21), the Labour Court of South Africa considered a review application under section 145 of the Labour Relations Act (LRA) concerning an arbitration award handed down by a CCMA commissioner. The matter originated when an employee referred an unfair dismissal dispute to the CCMA, citing 'reasons unknown' following the termination of his employment amidst group restructuring and business rescue proceedings. The arbitrator subsequently ruled that the dismissal was substantively and procedurally unfair, awarding compensation against the group’s holding company and operating division. The employer parties applied to review and set aside the award on jurisdictional grounds, arguing that the CCMA lacked jurisdiction to arbitrate the dispute.

The court first addressed the issue of employer identity and the joinder of non-referred parties, holding that the arbitrator erred in determining the true employer. The objective evidence established that the employee was employed by an operating company under business rescue, rather than the holding companies against which relief was granted or sought. Furthermore, the court held that joining additional corporate entities post-conciliation is legally incompetent if no prior section 191 referral was served directly on them. Disregarding separate corporate personalities to extend liability to holding entities without establishing grounds to pierce the corporate veil constituted a fundamental error of law.

On the question of jurisdictional subject-matter, the court held that courts and commissioners must determine the true nature of a dispute from the objective facts rather than accepting a partys categorization. The evidence demonstrated that the termination stemmed directly from a business rescue plan resulting in enterprise-wide retrenchments for operational requirements. Under section 191 of the LRA, where a dispute concerns dismissals based on operational requirements following a multi-employee retrenchment process, the CCMA lacks jurisdiction to arbitrate, as sole jurisdiction rests with the Labour Court.

The court applied a de novo standard of review appropriate for jurisdictional challenges rather than the reasonable decision-maker test. The Labour Court granted the review application and set aside the arbitrator’s award for lack of jurisdiction. The award was substituted with a determination dismissing the matter for want of CCMA jurisdiction,

Aansoeke deur paartjies / couples ook welkom....sluitingsdatum vir aansoeke uitgestel tot VRYDAG 9 OKTOBER 2026.
07/10/2026

Aansoeke deur paartjies / couples ook welkom....sluitingsdatum vir aansoeke uitgestel tot VRYDAG 9 OKTOBER 2026.

DISMISSAL AND PROTECTED DISCLOSUREMr Mazibuko was employed by AEL Mining as Contracts Manager at De Beers’ Venetia mine,...
03/10/2026

DISMISSAL AND PROTECTED DISCLOSURE

Mr Mazibuko was employed by AEL Mining as Contracts Manager at De Beers’ Venetia mine, where AEL provided blasting services. De Beers’ Mine Manager raised concerns with Mazibuko about low morale among AEL’s blasters. Mazibuko established that the blasters complained that they performed substantially the same work as higher-paid Technical Officers while remaining employed and remunerated as lower-grade blasters. AEL’s fixed-cost schedule with De Beers provided for Technical Officers, and Mazibuko raised the discrepancy internally several times, warning that it affected morale and posed a risk to operations and AEL’s contract. AEL’s response was that blasters would remain employed and paid as blasters. When the Mine Manager later asked whether De Beers was paying for Technical Officers or blasters, Mazibuko replied that De Beers was paying for Technical Officers and explained the concern he had raised internally.

AEL suspended Mazibuko shortly after that communication and charged him with gross misconduct for engaging De Beers without authorisation concerning remuneration and payment of blasters, thereby allegedly jeopardising the client relationship and bringing AEL into disrepute. He was dismissed. Mazibuko claimed that the dismissal was automatically unfair under section 187(1)(h) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 because it followed a protected disclosure under the Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000.

Mazibuko reasonably believed that AEL was requiring blasters to perform higher-grade work while remunerating them at the lower grade, while De Beers was paying for Technical Officers. For protection under section 9, the disclosure had to be made in good faith, on a reasonable belief that the information was substantially true, without personal gain, satisfy one of the section 9(2) conditions, and be reasonable in all the circumstances.

Mazibuko’s email constituted a disclosure because he had reason to believe the information tended to show non-compliance with legal obligations towards the blasters and raised concerns about AEL’s obligations to De Beers. The section 9 requirements were met. The disclosure was made in good faith, the information was reasonably believed to be substantially true and there was no ulterior purpose or personal gain. It was reasonable to answer the Mine Manager’s direct question honestly, particularly because the Mine Manager had raised the morale issue initially and Mazibuko was responsible for managing risks to the client relationship. The disclosure was the direct and proximate cause of the disciplinary proceedings and dismissal.

Mazibuko’s dismissal was declared automatically unfair. AEL was ordered to pay compensation of R1,981,123.20, equivalent to 24 months’ remuneration.

Mazibuko v AEL Mining Services (Pty) Ltd (JS392/2021) [2026] ZALCJHB 324 (15 September 2026)

22/09/2026

Many employees believe that untaken annual leave automatically accumulates and will result in a substantial payout when employment ends. However, the BCEA takes a different approach.

By Carl Ranger
Head of Training at Consolidated Employers Organisation (CEO SA)

https://ceosa.org.za/infographic-what-happens-to-untaken-leave/

16/09/2026

🌿 WE'RE HIRING: CLUB OPERATIONS MANAGER 🌿

QUAGGASKLOOF WATERSKI KLUB, WORCESTER
Are you an experienced, hands-on manager who thrives in a busy environment and enjoys working with people, facilities and day-to-day operations?

QUAGGAS is looking for a capable and energetic Club Operations Manager to take responsibility for the smooth, efficient and professional running of our Club.

This is a hands-on management role suited to someone who can lead a team, solve problems, manage facilities and contractors, engage confidently with members and visitors, and ensure that things get done. The successful candidate will be the senior operational presence on site and will be expected to take ownership of the Club's day-to-day functioning, particularly over weekends, peak periods and major Club events.

⭐ THE ROLE

As Club Operations Manager, you will oversee the Club's day-to-day operations, including:

• 👥 Staff management – supervising operational, grounds, gate, bar and visitor-facing staff, including rosters, attendance, performance and day-to-day team coordination.
• 🏡 Club facilities – overseeing the clubhouse, camping area, grounds, buildings, equipment and general facilities, with a visible and hands-on presence across the Club.
• 🔧 Maintenance & contractors – coordinating repairs, maintenance, contractors, building work and renovations.
• 🍻 Bar operations – overseeing bar staff, stock control, Yoco/POS procedures, cash-up controls, stock variances and day-to-day bar operations to maintain strong operational control and minimise losses.
• 😊 Member, visitor & camping experience – coordinating weekend and peak-period visitor and camping operations and dealing professionally with queries, complaints, incidents and operational concerns.
• 🔐 Rules, access & safety – ensuring Club rules, access-control procedures and safety requirements are implemented.
• 📋 Operational administration – providing accurate operational information to Trafalgar and the Club administration office, following up outstanding matters and ensuring that operational information is properly communicated.
• 💰 Budgets & expenditure – assisting with operational planning, budgets and expenditure monitoring.
• 📊 Committee reporting – providing regular operational reports and assisting with the implementation of Committee decisions and policies.

🎯 WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR

We are looking for someone who is:

✔ An experienced operational or general manager
✔ A confident and effective people manager
✔ Highly visible, hands-on and comfortable managing operations on site
✔ Organised, practical and solution-focused
✔ Comfortable dealing with members, visitors, campers, staff and contractors
✔ Able to manage multiple priorities in a busy environment
✔ Confident in enforcing rules and maintaining standards
✔ Financially and administratively astute
✔ A strong communicator with excellent interpersonal skills
✔ Reliable, accountable and willing to take ownership
✔ Available and willing to work weekends, public holidays and peak holiday periods as a core part of the role when Club operations require it

📌 MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
• Grade 12 / National Senior Certificate
• 3–5 years' relevant operational, supervisory or management experience
• Proven staff-management experience
• Experience in facilities, maintenance and contractor coordination
• Experience with customer/member service, visitor operations and complaint handling
• Experience with stock control and preferably bar/POS operations, including cash-up and stock-variance controls
• Basic financial and administrative management experience
• Computer literacy, including Microsoft Word, Excel and email
• Excellent communication skills
• Valid driver's licence

🎓 ADVANTAGEOUS
A relevant qualification in Hospitality, Operations Management, Facilities Management, Tourism, General Management or a related field will be advantageous.

📩 HOW TO APPLY
Please submit by email to [email protected]:

• Comprehensive CV
• Copies of relevant qualifications
• Details of at least three employment references
• Brief motivation outlining your suitability for the position
📍 Worcester
💰 Offering a competitive and market related monthly salary (depending on qualifications and experience)
📅 Closing date: 30 SEPTEMBER 2026
📅 Commencement: AS SOON AS POSSIBLE

Only shortlisted candidates will be contacted.

QUAGGASKLOOF WATERSKI CLUB reserves the right not to make an appointment and the appointment will be subject to the Club's standard recruitment and verification processes.
If you have not received any feedback within 2 weeks of closing of application date, your application was unsuccessful.

15/09/2026

LABOUR – RECUSAL AND ALLEGED BIAS OF ARBITRATOR

Mr Adams, employed by the Department of Trade, applied unsuccessfully for a post in the Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS). He was not shortlisted because DWS considered that his qualifications did not meet the stipulated NQF Level 7 requirements. Adams referred an unfair labour practice dispute to the General Public Service Sectoral Bargaining Council and represented himself at arbitration, while DWS was represented by two legally trained representatives. During the hearing they repeatedly interrupted Adams while he was explaining his case and while giving evidence-in-chief. The arbitrator occasionally cautioned them but largely allowed the interruptions to continue.

Adams applied for the arbitrator’s recusal, alleging that the arbitrator was biased, had effectively become a “third legal opponent”, had failed to protect him as a lay litigant, and had favoured DWS procedurally. The immediate trigger was the arbitrator’s direction that DWS bring a formal application to compel disclosure of Adams’s past performance agreements and assessments.

Most of Adams’s complaints concerning admissibility of evidence, disclosure, the use of another CV and other evidentiary rulings were matters capable of being corrected on review of a final award and did not justify premature intervention. The recusal issue was different because it concerned whether the proceedings had already been tainted so that a fair hearing could no longer reasonably be expected. The transcript showed persistent interruptions by both DWS representatives during Adams’s presentation and evidence-in-chief, often raising matters properly reserved for cross-examination.

The arbitrator did not exercise sufficient control over the hearing. Although he was entitled to conduct the arbitration adversarially and had on occasion cautioned the representatives, the frequency and nature of the interruptions required a firmer response. Allowing two legally trained representatives repeatedly to interject while a self-represented litigant was presenting his case and evidence created a lopsided process. A reasonable litigant could therefore apprehend that the hearing would not be fair. This conclusion did not depend on Adams’s concerns about the prospective disclosure ruling.

The recusal ruling was reviewed and set aside and substituted with a ruling granting Adams’s recusal application. The arbitrator was recused. The dispute was remitted to the bargaining council for a hearing de novo before another arbitrator within 30 calendar days of receipt of the order. No order was made as to costs.

Adams v General Public Service Sectoral Bargaining Council and Others (C382/2023) [2026] ZALCCT 147 (3 September 2026)

Address

Worcester

Opening Hours

Monday 08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday 08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday 08:00 - 17:00
Thursday 08:00 - 18:00
Friday 08:00 - 17:00

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Winelands Consulting posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share