Play It Again Sports - Hilliard, OH

Play It Again Sports - Hilliard, OH We specialize in fitness, football, baseball, lacrosse, and hockey equipment. Our lineup of sporting equipment includes plenty of top brand-name options.

When it comes to the equipment you need, new or used, we are your premier sporting goods store in Hilliard, OH. At Play It Again Sports Hilliard, we specialize in fitness, football, baseball, softball, golf, lacrosse, and hockey equipment. We provide the best-fit sports gear that athletes need to play their games, from hockey skates to lacrosse sticks. It's our job and pride to ensure this equipme

nt is right for you and your sport - and most importantly, that it performs for you. And if you have some used equipment that's in good condition and no longer need it, get in touch! We're proud to offer top dollar for your used equipment. Visit us today!

05/22/2026

We have HUNDREDS of used cleats in stock!
Look for letters on the bottom of the soles.
A- $24.99
B- $19.99
C- $14.99

4720 Cemetery Rd.
Hilliard, Ohio 43026
Mon-Sat 10-8 Sun 11-5

IF YOU ARE ON THE WAITLIST AND HAVE NOT YET PICKED UP, YOU HAVE UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY TOMORROW MAY 20th!! Whatever re...
05/19/2026

IF YOU ARE ON THE WAITLIST AND HAVE NOT YET PICKED UP, YOU HAVE UNTIL THE END OF THE DAY TOMORROW MAY 20th!!
Whatever remains after tmrw will be sold on Wednesday.

PLEASE HURRY IN TO CLAIM YOUR HACKY SACK!

DIRTBAGS AND BOOTA BAGS ARE IN STOCK!!Everyone on our waitlist will get 1.25 more are up for grabs for the first people ...
05/19/2026

DIRTBAGS AND BOOTA BAGS ARE IN STOCK!!
Everyone on our waitlist will get 1.
25 more are up for grabs for the first people in!
Maximum limit of 2.

4720 Cemetery Rd.
Hilliard, Ohio 43026
Mon-Sat 10-8 Sun 11-5

UNIQUE ITEM ALERT: Check out this awesome Tennis Tutor ProLite Plus! It comes with a built in oscillator, 110 ball capac...
05/18/2026

UNIQUE ITEM ALERT: Check out this awesome Tennis Tutor ProLite Plus! It comes with a built in oscillator, 110 ball capacity, 2 button remote, and can even put top spin on the ball! Stop in a check it out before it's gone!

05/17/2026

Heighten your game with used equipment from Play It Again Sports!! 😂

New Summer Hours!
4720 Cemetery Rd.
Hilliard, Ohio 43026
Mon-Sat 10-8 Sun 11-5

DEAL OF THE DAY: A Jugs 85000 pitching machine! This weekend, mention our social media and pick it up for $399.99! With ...
05/16/2026

DEAL OF THE DAY: A Jugs 85000 pitching machine! This weekend, mention our social media and pick it up for $399.99! With speeds up to 50mph, this machine is perfect for coaching younger baseball and softball players!

Our newest Heart of the Hides just hit the shelves and they are SPICY! Bring in your gently used mitt and trade towards ...
05/13/2026

Our newest Heart of the Hides just hit the shelves and they are SPICY! Bring in your gently used mitt and trade towards one of these bad boys before they're gone.

Don't forget our premium mitts come with a FREE basic break in or a $20 premium break in to get you playing faster!

BUY OF THE DAY: Check out this amazing STX Aria Pro women's lacrosse stick! The Aria is perfect for higher level players...
05/11/2026

BUY OF THE DAY: Check out this amazing STX Aria Pro women's lacrosse stick! The Aria is perfect for higher level players looking for a lighter, faster stick. With a composite handle, hybrid pocket, and STX's 10 degree tech, this stick is gorgeous!

Today's the last day of our flash sale! Don't miss this chance to pick up your dream new baseball/softball bat or glove ...
05/10/2026

Today's the last day of our flash sale! Don't miss this chance to pick up your dream new baseball/softball bat or glove for 25% OFF! Bring in your gently used glove and trade to save even more!

WEEKEND FLASH SALE: 25% OFF New Baseball/Softball Bats, gloves, and batting gloves. Don't forget to bring in your gently...
05/09/2026

WEEKEND FLASH SALE: 25% OFF New Baseball/Softball Bats, gloves, and batting gloves. Don't forget to bring in your gently used bats and gloves to trade and save EVEN MORE!

Roll into summer with a great gently used bike from Play It Again Sports in Hilliard! We've got cruisers, road bikes, mo...
05/06/2026

Roll into summer with a great gently used bike from Play It Again Sports in Hilliard! We've got cruisers, road bikes, mountain bikes and more, and our stock changes constantly! Not riding much anymore? Bring up your bike and let us make an offer! The inspection takes 10-15 minutes and we can pay you on the spot!

Address

4720 Cemetery Road
Hilliard, OH
43026

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 11am - 5pm

Telephone

+16145299100

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Play It Again Sports - Hilliard, OH posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Play It Again Sports - Hilliard, OH:

Shortcuts

Share

Category