09/08/2026
Build Over It!
What do you do when you have 261,000 buildable square feet of development potential, but the buildings underneath it aren’t going anywhere?
That was the challenge we faced at 201 West 92nd Street and 200 West 93rd Street on the Upper West Side.
The properties comprised the entire Amsterdam Avenue blockfront between West 92nd and West 93rd Streets. Both we and the ownership believed development represented the highest and best use of the property.
There was only one problem.
The site consisted of two six-story apartment buildings filled with residential tenants, many of whom were rent stabilized, along with several ground-floor retail tenants.
Demolishing the buildings and creating a conventional development site simply wasn’t realistic.
But sitting above those buildings was approximately 261,000 square feet of unused development potential.
So, how do you unlock all of that value?
We approached the retail tenants with the longest remaining lease terms to determine whether they would consider buyouts, giving prospective purchasers greater clarity regarding which spaces might ultimately be vacated and at what cost.
The residential tenants were a different story. There was no realistic path to obtaining possession of the buildings.
So rather than trying to eliminate the problem, we focused on designing around it.
Given the configuration of the existing buildings, we developed a concept whereby structural steel could be driven through portions of the setbacks and air shafts and down into the bedrock. That structure could support a platform above the buildings, creating an entirely new development plane.
In other words, instead of knocking the buildings down, a developer could potentially build a new building on top of them!
We also commissioned view studies demonstrating that upper-floor apartments facing east could have views toward Central Park. Needless to say, this was not a development opportunity for everyone.
Nevertheless, our marketing process generated 11 offers from developers willing to tackle the challenge.
Ultimately, we found the right buyer.
Kent Swig of Swig Burris Equities envisioned constructing an approximately eight-foot-thick concrete platform above the existing buildings, creating the foundation upon which an entirely new building could rise.
The property sold for $54,000,000, or $206.90 per buildable square foot.
Sometimes maximizing value isn’t about removing the obstacle. Sometimes it is about finding the buyer who knows how to build around it.
Here is what the seller had to say:
“We wanted to find a buyer who believed in the development potential of our property. Bob Knakal and his team found the perfect buyer for our site and we could not be happier with the results. We highly recommend him to the sellers of any property in New York City. They are the best in the business.”
— Jeffrey Laska, Laska Family Trust