09/30/2026
McPHERSON’S QUICK LESSON #4 — ANSWER REVEAL!
Earlier today, I asked:
Can a New York Notary Public refuse to notarize a document?
And the answer is...
✅ YES!
Having a document and identification does not automatically mean that a notarization can—or should—take place.
A New York Notary Public has a responsibility to make sure the requirements for the notarial act are satisfied. In some circumstances, the notary must refuse to proceed. In others, the notary may refuse based on legitimate concerns.
⚖️ WHEN MUST A NOTARY REFUSE?
A New York Notary must refuse to perform the notarial act when the applicable requirements are not met.
That can include situations where the notary cannot properly complete the required notarial act or other regulatory requirements have not been satisfied.
💙 WHAT ABOUT THE SIGNER?
A notary may also refuse when the notary is not satisfied that the signer has the competence or capacity to execute the record or is not satisfied that the signer is signing knowingly and voluntarily.
That matters because a notarization should never be treated as simply:
“Show me your ID, sign here, and I'll stamp it.”
The notary has responsibilities that go beyond applying a stamp.
🚨 AND HERE’S AN IMPORTANT ONE — CONFLICT OF INTEREST
A New York Notary must remain impartial.
If the notary is a party to the transaction or is directly and financially interested in the transaction, the notary must disqualify themselves from performing that notarial act.
For example, New York's official Notary Public License Law explains that a notary who is a grantee or mortgagee in a conveyance or mortgage is disqualified from taking the acknowledgment of the grantor or mortgagor. It also makes clear that a notary cannot take their own acknowledgment.
Why?
Because a Notary Public is expected to be impartial. A direct financial interest in the transaction compromises that neutrality.
💡 TODAY’S QUICK LESSON TAKEAWAY
Can a New York Notary Public refuse to notarize?
✅ YES!
A notary isn't refusing simply to be difficult. There may be a legal or professional reason why the notarization cannot proceed.
MUST REFUSE:
❌ Requirements for the notarial act aren't met
❌ The notary is a party to the transaction
❌ The notary has a direct financial interest in the transaction
MAY REFUSE:
⚠️ Concerns about the signer's competence or capacity
⚠️ Concerns that the signer isn't acting knowingly or voluntarily
💙 Sometimes saying “NO” is part of protecting the integrity of the notarization.
Did you get today's answer right? 👀
Tell me YES or NO in the comments! 👇🏽
And come back next Wednesday for another McPherson’s Quick Lesson!
One Question. One Answer. Real Knowledge.
📞 914-396-6703
✉️ [email protected]
McPherson’s Next Level Documents & Notary Services
Taking Your Documents to the Next Level.